FOR Many in the Southern cities, weekend is never complete without watching the unassuming debate show of Neeya Naana Anchored by Gopinath who took pride in prefixing the title As Neeya Naana Gopinath,which has been watched( pls note I never said admired) by many for the controversial topics.
Many topics have been in discussions, ranging from ethics ,relationships, dress sense,character marriages and even about the existence of super natural powers etc
Many topics have been in discussions, ranging from ethics ,relationships, dress sense,character marriages and even about the existence of super natural powers etc
And every topic taken for discussion was truly controversial in its own way. On many days even while the show was more serious arguments have erupted within the family members debating for and against the views being expressed and aired.And many weeks ended with either ,the couples/children/parents tugging on to their views and having small break ups too.
The debater had never spared any person/topic untouched be it Father, Mother ,friends ,teachers,mentor,God, system of beliefs, prayers etc etc. But never there was ever a slight resistance both from the participants or from the audience saying / claiming that the Discussions were unfair/ biased and it could lead to lopsided mindset among st the viewers and in later days culminate into a societal issue.
The Anchor predominantly time and again endorsed all negative comments,Adding fuel to the thought process and commented that it was a mis representation of facts and this attitude of the anchor was never contested by any community, which gave him the leverage to assume that every word spoken or views expressed was authentic and final.in his parlance until recently.
A show of by Gopinath targeting the medical professionals regarding unethical practices followed by doctors which has come in for more criticism and kindled angst amongst the Doctor community,
In fact such rebuttals should have come in from every one,Parent,Teacher,Brother Sister,etc earlier itself when ever they were targeted, While they were the subjects of discussions because the comments and views and analogy were indeed a dose of bitter pill to ingest causing irk among every segment of people.because the discussions were really not consistent and acceptable in reality.
However since the TRP rating of this show kept going up due to the absence of protest from every one the TV channel and the Anchor believe that what ever was aired was non controversial and in sync with the Society,till the recent episode.
Well a group of professionals (Doctors)have reacted sharply against the views expressed during the show,I as a non Medical person would like to place my understanding and interpretations as follows,
Is it not a fact that the diagnosis of any ailment by a doctor on date, is linked to a series of investigation and tests,and finally confirmed by the doctor for the line of treatment/Management TO BE INITIATED.
Was it not earlier the skill AND knowledge of the physician in diagnosing the ailment with a physical examination and with an extensive interaction with the patient, where has this art been buried ?
Does this indicate lack of confidence,from our physicians that he depend s upon numerical values and pictured scans to start the treatment, Isn't this attitude amply justifying that Today's Treatment are more investigation driven, without application of mind and Reasoning.Which in turn justified the debate.
Can we not attribute this trend to the fast pace at which our doctors would like to treat their patience(or get rid of them by prescribing some medicines only based on the test reports)Failing which He/she would have to limit themselves just seeing off hardly 5-6 patients in their scrambled time slot of an hour of consultation
which they have set aside,CONTRARY TO HAVE rendered consultation for atleast 15 -20 if the investigation results are there handy to draw course of action(commercialisation)
.
Does this theory not match with the opinion that every doctor wants to maximize their emoluments and hence follow these practices knowing very well that its unethical.
Yet another point of debate was regarding a confirmation test on pregnancy,Where one among the audience
indicated that just with a Stethoscope it can be done,which again gathered the wrath from the Doctors commune,
Well here again in my opinion the despair and depressing need to put off child birth in advanced countries would have initiated a need to have a fast track method to confirm a pregnancy, So that the earlier the better.Which is invariably being followed by every one today.
How many Doctors advise people to wait for a minimum period without proceeding with such confirmation test/and investigations.
Any lady who is ready to accept her pregnancy and await for her child would not resort to any major investigations because she may be the best judge to notice the progressive changes and confirm the new addition.Was it not like this a few decades back?
Just to add up to this list is the decision taken by our doctors to perform some major surgeries on Aged people,knowing very well that even recovery the surgical strain would require tremendous stress both to the care giver/patient .Are these surgeries not carried out just to lure patients with the tag line of giving quality life and cash less treatments at the behest of some insurance scheme While most of them are aimed at increasing their margin of profits(yet another) unethical way of making fast money
.
Well if these are some noticeable practices going on in the Medical profession.At the same time let us not isolate this trend to the Medical professionals alone as indicated Doctors are not trained to serve people but to meet the requirements of the Medical Business which is a part and parcel of our economy..
On the other hand their clients(the patients)who visit the doctors also go with a firm mindset,No one is ready to accept a doctor's prescribing a set of medicines with out doing some investigations at least a list of pathological tests.
More over they stamp the doctor who does not require a test report as either fake or incompetent..and start switching over to hospitals and private institutions sans the government hospitals who in fact extend far superior medical support and advice.
The debater had never spared any person/topic untouched be it Father, Mother ,friends ,teachers,mentor,God, system of beliefs, prayers etc etc. But never there was ever a slight resistance both from the participants or from the audience saying / claiming that the Discussions were unfair/ biased and it could lead to lopsided mindset among st the viewers and in later days culminate into a societal issue.
The Anchor predominantly time and again endorsed all negative comments,Adding fuel to the thought process and commented that it was a mis representation of facts and this attitude of the anchor was never contested by any community, which gave him the leverage to assume that every word spoken or views expressed was authentic and final.in his parlance until recently.
A show of by Gopinath targeting the medical professionals regarding unethical practices followed by doctors which has come in for more criticism and kindled angst amongst the Doctor community,
In fact such rebuttals should have come in from every one,Parent,Teacher,Brother Sister,etc earlier itself when ever they were targeted, While they were the subjects of discussions because the comments and views and analogy were indeed a dose of bitter pill to ingest causing irk among every segment of people.because the discussions were really not consistent and acceptable in reality.
However since the TRP rating of this show kept going up due to the absence of protest from every one the TV channel and the Anchor believe that what ever was aired was non controversial and in sync with the Society,till the recent episode.
Well a group of professionals (Doctors)have reacted sharply against the views expressed during the show,I as a non Medical person would like to place my understanding and interpretations as follows,
Is it not a fact that the diagnosis of any ailment by a doctor on date, is linked to a series of investigation and tests,and finally confirmed by the doctor for the line of treatment/Management TO BE INITIATED.
Was it not earlier the skill AND knowledge of the physician in diagnosing the ailment with a physical examination and with an extensive interaction with the patient, where has this art been buried ?
Does this indicate lack of confidence,from our physicians that he depend s upon numerical values and pictured scans to start the treatment, Isn't this attitude amply justifying that Today's Treatment are more investigation driven, without application of mind and Reasoning.Which in turn justified the debate.
Can we not attribute this trend to the fast pace at which our doctors would like to treat their patience(or get rid of them by prescribing some medicines only based on the test reports)Failing which He/she would have to limit themselves just seeing off hardly 5-6 patients in their scrambled time slot of an hour of consultation
which they have set aside,CONTRARY TO HAVE rendered consultation for atleast 15 -20 if the investigation results are there handy to draw course of action(commercialisation)
.
Does this theory not match with the opinion that every doctor wants to maximize their emoluments and hence follow these practices knowing very well that its unethical.
Yet another point of debate was regarding a confirmation test on pregnancy,Where one among the audience
indicated that just with a Stethoscope it can be done,which again gathered the wrath from the Doctors commune,
Well here again in my opinion the despair and depressing need to put off child birth in advanced countries would have initiated a need to have a fast track method to confirm a pregnancy, So that the earlier the better.Which is invariably being followed by every one today.
How many Doctors advise people to wait for a minimum period without proceeding with such confirmation test/and investigations.
Any lady who is ready to accept her pregnancy and await for her child would not resort to any major investigations because she may be the best judge to notice the progressive changes and confirm the new addition.Was it not like this a few decades back?
Just to add up to this list is the decision taken by our doctors to perform some major surgeries on Aged people,knowing very well that even recovery the surgical strain would require tremendous stress both to the care giver/patient .Are these surgeries not carried out just to lure patients with the tag line of giving quality life and cash less treatments at the behest of some insurance scheme While most of them are aimed at increasing their margin of profits(yet another) unethical way of making fast money
.
Well if these are some noticeable practices going on in the Medical profession.At the same time let us not isolate this trend to the Medical professionals alone as indicated Doctors are not trained to serve people but to meet the requirements of the Medical Business which is a part and parcel of our economy..
On the other hand their clients(the patients)who visit the doctors also go with a firm mindset,No one is ready to accept a doctor's prescribing a set of medicines with out doing some investigations at least a list of pathological tests.
More over they stamp the doctor who does not require a test report as either fake or incompetent..and start switching over to hospitals and private institutions sans the government hospitals who in fact extend far superior medical support and advice.